Talking and Teaching about Walls and Borders

U.S. Mexico Border

This post was updated on January 5, 2019

President Trump’s campaign promise to build a wall along the U.S. border with Mexico continues to generate controversy. Debates about funding, the purpose, and need for the wall often boil over, ending in talking heads raising their voices on 24-hour news channels. As we prepare to post this resource, the United States government is partially shut down over a dispute about funding for the wall.

Debates about the wall center on fundamental differences about the meaning and purpose of a border wall. Indeed, the wall itself means many things to different people. For some, it is an essential component of border security, others see the wall an insult to the Latinx community inside and outside of the United States, some see it as a way to prevent illegal border crossings, while others argue that it is a waste of money. Below you will find a curated collection of recent news stories about the wall, we have tried to represent a range of points of view and a variety of media to allow access for as many students as possible.

While discussions of contemporary migration are often polarized, they are essential. One reason that emotion about issues of migration run so strong is that debates over the movement of people are among the most important civic issues faced by societies around the world. They raise fundamental questions about inclusion and exclusion, identity, and national sovereignty. Below we introduce some context for discussing the wall, and an art based exercise intended to promote respectful reflection and discussion across difference.

Context:

Migration has been an essential part of the human experience well before the creation of national borders. Indeed, humans were migratory before they ever built cities. That said, it wasn’t too long after humans first built cities that they first began to build walls. They were created for defensive purposes, and to keep people considered undesirable, out.

Enforcement along the U.S. Mexico became an increasing priority for politicians after the 1965 immigration and naturalization act. Additional agents were sent to monitor border crossings. According to History.com, “The United States began the installation of border fences to restrict the movement of unlawful immigrants and drugs in 1993 when President Bill Clinton mandated the construction of a 14-mile barrier between San Diego and Tijuana. The Secure Fence Act of 2006 authorized the construction of 700 miles of border fencing and vehicle barriers, which was completed in 2011.”  Despite construction sections of border walls, undocumented migration rose throughout the 90s; however, it has decreased every year since 2007. Despite the decreasing numbers of undocumented border crossings, promises of a wall along the U.S./Mexico border became a central element of President Trump’s campaign for office.

Teaching Suggestions:

Instead of starting a lesson by delving into the middle of a controversy, we find it useful to provide a safe distance to begin reflection. In this case, we suggest using an image created by the French artist J.R.  The piece, a gigantic scaffolding installation featuring the photograph of Kikito, a one-year-old boy from Tecate, Mexico, was placed on the Mexican side of the border facing the United States. We suggest following these three simple directions for interpreting JR’s work and considering the message he is hoping to send.

Image:

Embed from Getty Images

The large photograph was constructed on the Mexican side of the border facing the United States. Click on the image for more information.

Slideshow:

This slideshow includes images that focus on the placement of J.R.’s “Kikito.”:

Embed from Getty Images

Three Directions:

  1. Begin by working with students to describe what they see in each image. Encourage students to describe the image in as objective terms as possible. In the case of these two images, include information about not only the art piece itself as well as where it is placed and its relationship to that space.
  2. Analyze what you see – what details do students notice, and what do they think they mean in the context of the work. We often begin this activity in a whole group, but eventually, encourage students to do this work in small groups or pairs.
  3. For the final step, interpret the work – working from the details and the image analysis, ask students to come up with their own interpretation of the overall message of the work. We often ask students to write this in a journal or on a piece of paper before asking them to share their ideas with a partner.

As a whole group, discuss the range of interpretations of the work. What themes emerge? What differences did you notice between interpretations? And, how do you account for those differences?

You might also consider following a similar protocol for interpreting a second J.R. image that was placed along the U.S./Mexico border. This commentary published Latino USA explores the way that artists can reshape our understanding of the border. The authors write:

The arts have played a central role in forming narratives of identity and place. Whether through music or through visuals, the arts have a particular sensory and discursive power to shape consciousness and understanding of people and spaces.

As the border art suggests, debates about the wall are about more than funding and plans for construction. Deeply connected to discussions about the wall is a range of issues related to immigration. We frequently use the iceberg diagram strategy to help make the various issues that come together in a civic debate visible. Instead of telling students what you believe is fueling the border debates, ask them what they believe is below the surface.

To conclude, we like to employ Project Zero thinking routines to help students to recognize the significance of a particular public debate. In this case consider using the Three Whys. Ask students:

  1. Why does this matter to me?
  2. Why does this matter to my community? (you might replace this question with: why does this matter to the country?).
  3. Why does this matter to the world?

Extension:

Encourage students to think critically about their knowledge of the discussions of a border wall in the U.S. In this variation of a K-W-L chart, ask students first to list information that they are confident they know is true related to debates about the wall. As students list information, explain that you are looking for verifiable facts. In a separate category ask students to record what they have heard that they have not verified or are unable to confirm.

Ask students to do their best to identify the sources of information in this category, which could influence both rumors. Ask students how they might be able to asses the validity of the information in the second column.

Below we have included a variety of news sources students could use extend their understanding of the issues involved. As students read the various sources, encourage them to be aware of the various perspectives offered in the text. Consider asking them to use another Project Zero thinking routine as they gather information. This routine is called Step In – Step Out – Step Back. Here is how it works:

Step-in, step-out, step-back 

  1. Choose: Identify a person or agent in the situation you are examining
  2. Step In: Given what you see and know at this time, what do you think this person might feel, believe, know, or experience?
  3. Step out: What else would you like or need to learn to understand this person’s perspective better?
  4. Step back: Given your exploration of this perspective so far, what do you notice about your own perspective and what it takes to take somebody else’s?

Depending on the direction you hope to take the discussion, we suggest two different ways for students to demonstrate an understanding of the issues at stake.

  • Begin a think-pair-share activity by inviting students to reflect on the importance and meaning of borders.
    • What are borders?
    • What purposes do they serve?
    • How are national borders similar to other borders?
    • In what ways, are they different?
  • Working individually or in groups ask students to prepare a one-page policy recommendation in the form of a memorandum regarding the border wall that includes a justification for their position. You might offer students a chance to present their proposals to their peers, or to craft letters to political representatives describing their understanding of the issues involved.
    • A Memorandum usually includes four parts:
      • 1. An Introduction
      • 2. A Statement of the facts about the issue.
      • 3. The Argument you are making.
      • 4. A conclusion, which typically includes a call to action.

Teaching Resources:

Deconstructing the Wall: Teaching About the Symbolism, Politics and Reality of the U.S.-Mexico Border via NY Times Learning, January 6, 2019.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/06/learning/lesson-plans/border-wall-lesson-plan.html

News Sources:

Standoff: Trump Wants $5 Billion For Wall, Democrats Offer $1.3B For Border Security via NPR, January 3, 2019

Trump: Government won’t reopen ‘until we have a wall via PBS Newshour, December 25, 2018, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-government-wont-reopen-until-we-have-a-wall

While the US debates caravans and wall, thousands of migrants are dumped in border cities via USA Today, December 28, 2018 https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2018/12/28/us-mexico-border-migrants-dumped-america-border-cities/2431494002/

The Border Wall: How a Potent Symbol Is Now Boxing Trump In via New York Times, January 5, 2019

For context on current debates about the border, consider these news sources:

Everything You Need to Know About the Mexico-United States Border:
https://www.history.com/news/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-mexico-united-states-border 

The Border Wall: What has Trump Built So Far:                                                                                                                                               https://nyti.ms/2RuJBqi

US Mexico Border History Photos 2017:
https://www.businessinsider.com/us-mexico-border-history-photos-2017-4 

A look at U.S. policy toward immigration and border security with Mexico over the past 60 yearshttp://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/stories/mexico704/history/timeline.html# 

US Unauthorized Immigrant Total Dips to Lowest Level in a Decade:
http://www.pewhispanic.org/2018/11/27/u-s-unauthorized-immigrant-total-dips-to-lowest-level-in-a-decade/

The Raging Controversy at the Border Began With This Incident 100 Years Ago
In Nogales, Arizona, the United States and Mexico agreed to build walls separating their countries via Smithsonian Magazine, July 2018, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/raging-controversy-border-began-100-years-ago-180969343/#CZVxSlEfHszuc5K5.99