Article: The doner kebab, an unlikely symbol of European identity

The doner kebab, a typical “German” meal?
Jason M Ramos, CC BY

Pierre Raffard, Sorbonne Université

Has the doner kebab become a political issue in Europe? While the idea might seem humorous, this is a serious question. Alongside the hamburger, the doner kebab is one of France’s most popular fast-food dishes. It has also attracted unexpected attention and controversy, and raised previously unexplored cultural issues.

In December 2017 the health committee of the European Parliament voted to ban phosphate additives used in frozen kebab meat. This was supposed to be a simple administrative adjustment for public-health reasons, but the decision sparked an outcry and the issue became an unlikely political football.

Does the doner kebab need to be ‘saved’?

German European deputy Renate Sommer (CDU) took the first shot, asserting on her Facebook page that the decision would penalise owners of small restaurants and possibly lead to the loss of thousands of jobs.

The story grew and was soon taken up by European media: Bild repeated the Ms. Sommer’s concerns, and The Guardian, La Repubblica and El País quickly followed suit.

Due to the uproar, two weeks later the European parliament used an upcoming evaluation by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) as an excuse to postpone the decision.

While it might seem like a tempest in a teacup, the incident isn’t as minor as it might appear at the outset. The wave of reactions, ranging from despair and outrage to amusement and delight, demonstrated that behind the doner kebab’s modest façade, it is in fact a symbol of the social, political and identity issues facing European societies today.

Paristanbul, Paris.
Gideon/Flickr, CC BY

A love-hate relationship with the doner kebab

The European story of the doner kebab is first and foremost one of the astounding success of a dish that, against all odds, became both the labourer’s meal of choice and the quintessential midnight snack.

The doner kebab arrived in Europe in the mid-1930s, when a handful of Greek and Armenian restaurant owners, exiled from Anatolia years earlier, decided to add it to their menus. At that time it was an unassuming dish known only to immigrants, who saw it as a cheap meal that also allowed them to preserve a symbolic link with their home countries.

The earliest known photo of the doner kebab, meat cooked on a vertical rotisserie, taken in the Ottoman Empire in 1855.
James Robertson/Wikimedia

Also known as the döner kebap, the dish and others like it spread across the world, where goes by names such as gyro (Greek), shawarma (Arabic) and al pastor (Spanish), with endless local variations.

It wasn’t until the 1980s and 1990s that the doner kebab really took off in Western Europe. As deindustrialisation hit, many laid-off workers, in particular those originally from Turkey, decided to try their hand at food service.

With no extensive culinary knowledge and little capital, many of these new entrepreneurs turned to the doner kebab. Their inexpensive restaurants chiefly targeted workers, students and immigrants looking for an unpretentious place to grab a meal day or night. The doner kebab proved to be unexpectedly popular and gradually carved out a place in European cities’ culinary and social landscapes.

Millions of doner kebabs every day

A pizza-kebab hybrid on the menu at the pizzeria La Bella, in Sweden, 2013.
Gunnar Creutz/Wikimedia, CC BY-ND

The rise in popularity of the doner kebab has been staggering. In Paris alone, there are now over 550 doner kebab shops. In the United Kingdom, they’re reportedly sold in 17,000 businesses. And in Germany, the European heartland of the doner kebab, 2 million were eaten daily in 2017.

This success is even more surprising given that it doesn’t depend on a monopoly by a globe-spanning food conglomerate, but on the (partly subconscious) “genius” of tens of thousands of independent food sellers. Not only do they serve a satisfying meal that meets the cultural and ethical standards of consumers – particularly with halal meat – but they also to keep up with swiftly changing European eating habits.

Success has come at a price, however. As its popularity has grown, the doner kebab has faced increasing wariness. There has been a myriad of articles and reports about the unsanitary conditions of some shops, associating the doner kebab in the minds of the public as a fatty, unappetising meal made with dubious meat.

The French program Envoyé Spécial reported on the topic in 2016.

‘The immigrants’ gift to Europe’

Despite its occasionally unappealing image, the doner kebab has found enthusiastic support among an immense number of European residents. For them it’s not only a reasonably priced and tasty meal, but also a vibrant example of the value of cultural exchange.

In her 1999 research article “McDoener: Döner Kebab and the social positioning struggle of German Turks”, researcher Ayşe Çağlar explored the often positive associations between the doner kebab and Turkish immigrants in Germany. “The doner kebab has become part of the discourse surrounding the ‘issue of foreigners’ in Germany”, Ayşe wrote, citing slogans shouted at demonstrations in support of foreigners in 1980s Berlin: “Without foreigners, no doner kebabs!” and “Without us, no doner kebabs!”

This cultural and political association far from being specific just to Germany. For a Los Angeles Times reporter, the doner kebab is nothing less than the “Turkish immigrant’s gift to Germany”.

According to Ibrahim Doğuş, president of the Centre for Turkey Studies and director of the British Kebab Awards:

“The humble kebab holds a powerful message about a successful example of integration. It unites both newcomers and native eaters.”

Stash that kebab…

But this point of view does not find favour with everyone. In January 2009, Tuscan city of Lucca kicked off the hostilities. The town council decided to ban “establishments whose activities can be tracked to different ethnicities”, arguing the need to safeguard “culinary traditions and the authenticity of our architecture, culture and history”. (Whether the measure was also intended to ban US fast-food chains was not clear.) Similar measures were put in place in Italian towns such as Forte dei Marmi, Padua, Capriate San Gervasio and Verona.

When right-wing politician Robert Ménard was elected mayor of Béziers, France, in 2014, he proclaimed his wish to see doner kebab sellers disappear from the city’s historic center. While Ménard’s assertion led to no action in Béziers, such announcements demonstrate that the doner kebab is far from a simple late-night snack.

A culinary symbol of successful multiculturalism for some, a supposed proof of rampant Islamisation for others, the doner kebab is a social phenomenon and a revealing mirror for issues of identity and political divisions in today’s European societies.

Translated from the French by Alice Heathwood for Fast ForWord and Leighton Walter Kille for The Conversation France.The Conversation

Pierre Raffard, Enseignant chercheur, co-directeur Food 2.0 Lab, Sorbonne Université

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Reflection Questions from Re-imagining Migration

  1. What is the relationship between food and identity? Are there examples of foods that make you feel connected to your family and/or cultural traditions? What are they?
  2. What needs to happen for food from one group to be seen as part of the larger culture? Why are some immigrant origin foods considered exotic while others are seen as mainstream?
  3. How do you explain the love/hate relationship with the doner kebap? How might you determine to what extent are these feelings about food or something else?
  4. What can we learn about the integration of an immigrant community from adoption, or rejection, of foods from that culture?  If food from an immigrant community is accepted, does that mean that the group itself is accepted?
  5. What are some foods you commonly encounter that originated from immigrant-origin communities?